Serving Monmouth County and the Surrounding Areas | 908-489-3061

Mr. Prime Old Tyme Butcher

Quality and Service


Lamb is an incredibly versatile meat and can be prepared in many different ways. It's a good source of protein, vitamins, and minerals like iron and calcium. While it is slightly higher in calories than other meats, it's high in "good" fats and can promote cardiovascular health.

Succulent American Lamb

Enjoy 2 filets mignons and chocolate-covered strawberries for just $31.99

Did you know that most lamb is imported from other countries like New Zealand?


At Mr. Prime Old Tyme Butcher, we only offer American lamb that doesn't have the gamey taste that imported lambs do.

Lamb raised and harvested in the USA

Providing you with the highest quality meats and specialty groceries

Stop by today and bring home the area's freshest meats.

75 Main St. in Manasquan, NJ

Because we specialize in quality, you can trust that you're getting the best meats, veggies, cheeses, and prepared meals available. Drop by our store today and check out our selection for yourself. Our inventory changes frequently because we're a small, family-owned and operated shop.